Common Sense Change Management (CSCM)

A follow-up to “Who Do You Trust?” and “Give Trust to Get Trust”

Every interaction is an opportunity to make a deposit or a withdrawal in the Bank Account of Trust. Early on, while you’re still building trust, a small mistake can cost you a lot. Later, once people see you as trustworthy, a similar mistake may cost you very little.

At a glance

Purpose Help everyone picture and understand how trust works: like a bank account, with deposits and withdrawals over time. They see how trust is built, how it’s lost, and what to do when they make a withdrawal.
When A follow-up session to Who Do You Trust? that reinforces it. Pairs with Give Trust to Get Trust.
Audience Everyone. You’re building trust across the whole organization, so the whole group needs it, not just the leaders. Being trustworthy is a Best Behavior expected of everyone.
Time About 15 to 20 minutes, at your group’s pace.
Materials A flip chart and two markers: black for the steps and honest mistakes, and red (or any color that stands out from black) for the betrayal. You draw the bank account as the group gives examples.

Why it matters

Trust works like a bank account. You make deposits, and you make withdrawals. It’s similar to Stephen Covey’s Emotional Bank Account, but it’s focused on trust and uses plain words and an example everyone easily understands.

This lesson is for everyone. Everyone in the room is already expected to be trustworthy, so everyone needs to understand how trust is built, how it’s lost, and what it costs. Leaders have triple duty: they need to be trusted like everyone else, they set the example, and they hold everyone to the expectation.

Every personal interaction is an opportunity to make a deposit or cause a withdrawal. The deposits are those behaviors from Who Do You Trust?: being honest, keeping your word, listening, being open and transparent. Big or small, each one counts. The withdrawals are the opposite: not following through, not listening, breaking a confidence, not admitting a mistake. One withdrawal can often wipe out several deposits.

Early on, deposits barely register. When people don’t know you yet, a deposit hardly moves your balance. You have to keep taking steps by making deposits, like climbing up a staircase one step at a time, building up your balance of trust.

Early on, a small mistake costs you a lot. A withdrawal early in a relationship doesn’t drop you one step. It may drop you five, six, or more steps, depending on how serious it is. They don’t know you or your intent yet, so they tend to assume the worst and question whether you can be trusted. “Is this going to happen again? Maybe they’re not who they say they are. Can I count on them?”

Later, as trust grows, even a more serious lapse may cost you very little. You’ve proven your intent with a high balance. Keep making deposits and keep proving you’re trustworthy, and any withdrawal costs less and less. A blip in an already big account is hardly noticed. People know your intent, and they know you didn’t do it on purpose. Over time, mistakes are seen as a rare oversight, not an intention. That’s the aha moment: we all make mistakes, and a healthy trust account absorbs them.

Betrayals are deliberate. Unlike an honest mistake, a betrayal is intentional, not an oversight. It’s a deliberate breach, like lying or betraying a confidence, and it empties the account. It’s questionable whether a betrayal can ever be overcome.

Sooner or later, one’s true colors come out. Some people deliberately make deposits to cover untrustworthy tendencies or motives. They hide those motives on purpose to deceive others, but at some point they show themselves. “I used you, I deceived you, and I’m in it for me.” They don’t belong in a Common Sense Change Management–led organization. Any betrayal needs to be addressed promptly and handled on its own, which is a topic for another lesson.

A lesson everyone understands and everyone is taught. Trust is a bedrock behavior in a CSCM-led organization or change initiative. A lack of trust is an anchor on every effort to improve. The Bank Account of Trust lesson is common sense, simple logic, and human nature anyone can understand. A complex theory or model isn’t going to work for everyone, and trust is expected of everyone. Teach the lesson. Reinforce it often. Mentioning the Bank Account of Trust brings back the memory of the lesson and its simple chart showing how trust is built.

The Bank Account of Trust

Below is the finished chart. You don’t walk in and draw it all at once. You build it piece by piece as you walk the group through each part: draw a few deposit steps up, then show a mistake and a drop (early on, it’s more than a few steps), then more deposit steps back up again. Take your time; the Quick Lesson Guide walks you through it step by step.

Bank Account of TrustMore trustNo trustStarting outOver timeEarly: a big dropSmaller dropSmall dipHardly a blipBetrayalAll is lost
The finished flip chart: black marker for the steps and honest mistakes, red marker for the betrayal.

Each deposit moves you up one step. Each honest mistake is a withdrawal: a big drop early on, a smaller one as the account grows, and finally it’s hardly a blip. As you go through the exercise, you draw the chart to show the progression of deposits and withdrawals.

Draw the chart without the betrayal at first; you add it later. When you get to the betrayal, talk it through with the group: discuss how serious it is and ask for examples. They’ve all been there and have examples to share. Then show it on the same chart with a red dashed line straight down. Talk about the impact on individuals and groups, then add the red arrow along the bottom with “All is lost” written above it.

Turnaround Story Example

The third all-workforce Learning Session. It was a couple of months into the Turnaround effort when we held the third Learning Session for the whole workforce. These learning and development sessions were something new and different in the company. This wasn’t some project. It was the deliberate development of behaviors, skills, and abilities for everyone.

None of the company’s other 25 facilities had ever done anything like this. Yes, there were occasional project sessions, but this was different: individual and group development for everyone, kept under the corporate radar, because it would have been seen as wasted effort with little or no payback. No one else spent time changing behaviors across the whole workforce, and none were deliberately learning to continuously seek new best practices for their processes.

By this time, we’d been working on trust for a while. When I drew the Bank Account of Trust during the session, something clicked. The employees were eager and excited to learn and share. It was obvious they felt valued and important. They could see the lesson in the staircase chart: they recalled how we’d started from scratch, the screwups, losing some ground, and climbing back. They shared their own examples, and we laughed about some of them. They knew from their own lives that trust really works this way.

What’s the point of this example? The lesson wasn’t a complex model or a psychological concept. It was developed for the whole workforce. That’s the real point here. It was purposely simple, logical, and easy to understand. It used something everyone already knows and experiences: a bank account. It applied CSCM’s common sense, simple logic, and human nature, in terms everyone understood, from the technical manager to the utility operator. The comparison, with its deposits and withdrawals, made sense, and it was easy to recall and accept.

For me personally, how quickly they accepted this lesson was feedback that what we were doing was truly taking hold. I knew it was time to take it up a notch and start to introduce best practices into our everyday processes. The fundamental behaviors were now present, understood, and accepted as being necessary, but they still needed reinforcement to turn them into routines, and for those routines to become everyday work habits.

Read the short version of the Turnaround Story at diyleadingchange.com.

Quick Lesson Guide

Make it your own. The questions, words, and quotes here are examples that have worked for us. Use them, or change them to fit your style, your group, the circumstances, and your organization. Engage your group so everyone takes an active part. Use your facilitation skills and have fun doing it.

Use the three ways people learn. People learn by seeing, hearing, and doing. In this lesson, you present it, they take part by sharing their own ideas and examples, and they watch the chart take shape. They see it, hear it, and take part in the dialogue.

  1. Start with what they’ve already learned. Reinforce what they learned before. Ask, “What did we learn from Who Do You Trust?” and “What does it mean to give trust to get trust?” Let them feed it back to you. Then ask, “Is there anything we missed? Has anyone used any of those lessons since the last session?” Use those facilitation skills to encourage participation.
  2. Introduce the bank account. “Did you ever think about trust being like a bank account? You go along making deposits and withdrawals, and you gradually build up a good balance. Let me draw it for you.” Draw the two lines on the flip chart: time across the bottom, and trust up the side, from no trust at the bottom to more trust at the top. Write “Bank Account of Trust” at the top. (See the chart above.)
  3. Ask for deposits. “What counts as a deposit?” Refer them to the list from Who Do You Trust?: honest, keeps their word, listens, and so on. As each one comes up, add a step to the line. Smaller steps early on: “They still don’t know you or trust you yet.”
  4. Ask for withdrawals. Ask what happens when you mess up: “You’re new. You didn’t follow through on something. What happens?” Then draw it: you don’t drop one step, you drop five, six, or more. Early on, you don’t have much credit to rely on. You’re not fully trusted yet. Then ask, “So what do you do about it?” Own it. No excuses. Have them give examples.
  5. Keep building. Draw more steps up, then another mistake. Ask, “Now they know you better. How far do you drop this time?” They’ll likely tell you it’s a smaller drop. Draw it, talk about it, and repeat until a mistake is hardly a blip.
  6. Name the aha moment. Say it out loud: “It looks like early on, a small mistake costs you a lot. Later, even a bigger mistake costs you little. You’ve earned a lot of trust, and we all make mistakes; a healthy account absorbs them.” Ask the group if they agree.
  7. Mistakes versus betrayals. Ask, “What about someone who lies, or betrays a confidence?” Mistakes cost less over time. Betrayals don’t. An account can be healthy until a deliberate betrayal empties it and leaves the person below where they started. On the same flip chart, pick a spot between the smaller drop and the small dip, and draw a red dashed line straight down to the bottom (red is best, but any color that stands out from black works). Discuss the immediate drop, and how the account is now overdrawn. Then draw a red arrow to the right and write “All is lost” above it. Everything they built is gone, and so is everything that would have come after. Talk through what it means, and ask, “Has anyone seen that happen?”
  8. Set the expectation. As you wrap up, remind them that we all know trust matters in how we get work done, and this is another tool to use for building trust.
  9. Make a statement and create a saying. “Every interaction is an opportunity to build trust or break trust.” Write it below the chart. Then remind them, “Trust is how we get work done here, and higher trust delivers faster and better results.”
  10. Close with the saying. “The Bank Account of Trust: keep making those deposits.” Or use one of your own that fits the circumstances.

For leaders

You have triple duty. Like everyone else in the room, you need to be trusted. On top of that, you need to show what being trustworthy looks like, and hold everyone accountable for making their best effort to be trustworthy.

Your early deposits are small. As a new leader, or early in a change initiative, every withdrawal costs you more than you think. You set the standard and everyone is watching. Go out of your way to make deliberate deposits. Recognize others’ deposits. Coach and counsel when you observe withdrawals. Encourage your managers to do likewise.

Keep making deposits. Small, steady deposits add up. Early on, people are watching your every interaction closely. Those deposits earn you an ever bigger balance in your trust account.

Go overboard on reinforcement. Go out of your way to set the example and use reminders. Early in your trust-building efforts, overdo the reinforcement. Use the sayings, and point out good examples and missed opportunities. Point out mishaps and mistakes with good judgment, to be helpful, not critical. Push your managers to do the same, and point out when you see them miss opportunities. Celebrate deposits with simple gestures, like a “Good job” on this or that. Early on, you’re the spark plug, and when they see it, they get it.

Make a mistake? Own it. It’s going to happen; no one’s perfect. Owning it is a deposit. It may be painful, but think about what happens if you don’t. Now it becomes two withdrawals: the mistake, and not owning it. Owning a mistake is both a deposit and a lesson for others who see you admit it or apologize: “Sorry, I should have done…”

Stories and sayings. “When you make the extra effort, you’re going to fall down a little more often.” Sayings like that, and great stories, will come out of the effort to build trust. When one catches on, especially one people get a kick out of or one that makes a great story, jump on it. Capture it, share it, and bring it up soon and often while the incident is fresh, then use it again when the time is right. “Remember when…” is great real-life reinforcement. Memory recall is a powerful way to make and reinforce a point.

Watch for people who only act trustworthy. Some people make deposits solely for themselves, not for the group. Some like to stir the pot, and some like being a negative influence. Let’s just say it: they like to keep things stirred up. Outwardly, they want their account to look healthy, but they enjoy playing their game in the background. Call them on it.

Betrayers. Then there are the true betrayers, who don’t buy in, don’t care, and have ulterior motives. They will eventually slip or show their true intent. Not everyone will put the good of the whole ahead of their own self-interest. Keep your eyes open, and judge people by what they do over time. Eventually, you’ll have to call their bluff. It’s your job, and trust me, everyone already knows who they are. If you don’t act, you’re punishing everyone else, you’re not being true to the cause, and you’re not being the leader a CSCM-led organization needs. It’s a huge withdrawal, close to a betrayal. Enough said.

To be noted: a betrayal is serious. If the topic of how to handle a betrayal comes up, handle it honestly. Talk openly about how disruptive and damaging a betrayal can be. Let the group know that a betrayal will be dealt with one-on-one, case by case. Each case stands on its own merit and must be weighed fairly, but it can’t be ignored. Explain that any action taken needs to be seen as fair and just, both to the individual and to the group affected.

The group expects and needs action to be taken; otherwise, it’s time for someone else to lead. If a second chance is given, it requires high expectations and commitment from the betrayer, with the understanding that any repeat is 100% unacceptable.

After the session

  • Use sayings tied to the lesson. “Was that a deposit or a withdrawal?” “Nice deposit you made there.” Internal sayings and regular comments get noticed and have power. They bring back the memory of the lesson, and because they came up in the organization, the group owns them. Behavior takes time to change, and every little reminder helps when it’s done the right way.
  • Leave a flip chart up. Find a place for “their chart” to hang for a while; it’s theirs, not a fancy poster. Wait until everyone has completed the lesson, then hang it. They’ll recall the session and the lesson. It reinforces the lesson every time people walk by.
  • Keep living it until you hear it back. When people start talking about deposits and withdrawals on their own, they own it. Then the flip chart can come down.
  • Facilitate it for everyone. Same lesson, same way, same name.

New to “Who Do You Trust?” Start there. Download the free guide (PDF), which includes the full, ready-to-run session. For more lessons, including Give Trust to Get Trust, see the Toolbox.

Preston, DIY Leading Change


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *