Common Sense Change Management (CSCM)

A five- to ten-minute follow-up to “Who Do You Trust?”

A lesson, and actions to take, when you want to start building trust with others. Most people won’t trust you right away, so you should go first: you give trust to get trust.

At a glance

Purpose To start building, and keep reinforcing, others’ trust in you. Change and improvement happen faster and more effectively among people and groups with higher levels of trust.
When In a learning session after Who Do You Trust?, and demonstrated early and often in a new change initiative, as learning, action, and reinforcement of trust.
Audience People and groups who don’t know you yet, who are learning to build trust themselves, or who are in the early stages of a change initiative. Also anyone you want a better working relationship with.
Time About 5 to 10 minutes, at your group’s pace.
Materials None. It’s a dialogue you lead, with examples, real or made up, so they get it.

Why it matters

Trust makes change easier. When trust is high, change and improvement are more effective and happen faster. You don’t have to explain every move, there’s no worry about a hidden agenda, and your actions have built-in credibility.

Most people won’t trust you at first. Only a few will trust you outright. With everyone else, you have to pass their test, and for some that’s a big hill to climb. At first, you can expect 70% or more not to trust you. Why should they? They don’t know you yet, so you have to earn their trust.

Change is a risk. To most people, it upsets their comfort and familiarity. Human nature resists the unknown and untested; behavior, routine, and habits rule the day. Change can look like a serious threat to the status quo. Face it: most people don’t trust you or your motives.

Take the risk first. The most direct and effective approach is for you to go first and trust them first. You demonstrate the very actions and behaviors from the Who Do You Trust? lesson, and you open yourself up to getting burned. You say what you do and do what you say, regardless of the outcome. Use common sense and pick these first actions wisely. You’re not betting the farm. At worst, you can expect a little disappointment.

Make it easy to trust you back. Giving trust first is common sense, simple logic, and human nature, and it’s a great first step for a new leader. It says: “I’m trusting you first. I’m opening the door for you to step through.” Make their risk of trusting you small, so it’s easier for them to try. When they do, acknowledge it as soon as possible, and reinforce their effort openly. It’s an achievement to be seen and shared by others. It’s a win-win.

Small wins spread. Others think, “Look, they tried it and didn’t get burned.” Those who are less risk-averse drop their guard a little: “Maybe I’ll go along too.” Each small win opens the door for others. Celebrate each one; it’s what Kotter calls a short-term win. But don’t stop, or you’ll lose momentum. Take ever bigger steps as your trust grows. The biggest resisters get dragged along. It all started with you giving trust first.

Keep trying. It often takes more than one try. They may question your motive at first, and others are surely watching. When the leader goes first and then tries again, others notice the effort. If your first effort fails, try again, maybe with something more comfortable, acceptable, and less risky for that person. As people return the trust, others will notice, and the word gets out: “Hey, this person’s all right!”

Put on your Psychology 101 hat. This isn’t rocket science. Step back and look at the people you’re trying to reach: who they are, how they work, and what they see as risky. How well you know and read your audience is what makes you a great leader and a great facilitator. This is where you shine, and it’s something no outsider can provide.

From the Turnaround Story

When I took over the failing facility, my biggest obstacle was that there was no existing level of trust. At any time, circumstances might trigger closure. Change needed to happen fast, and I was going to do a lot of things I couldn’t take the time to explain. Time was the enemy. I needed to gain their trust quickly to support the unusual and unorthodox actions I knew I’d be taking.

I began by being transparent, openly sharing and explaining the financials with the entire workforce. No facility management had ever done that with its workforce, and I was blunt about the facility’s lousy performance. I gave them valid reasons to improve, and they saw the need. Then I gave them ever higher levels of responsibility for the facility’s survival, taking on responsibilities that normally belonged only to management and professionals.

They responded and quickly took ownership. My managers were aghast: “What are you doing?” My answer: “They’re capable.” It was a risk, but it paid off as the workforce used more and more of their own capabilities, and management let go of more and more. I trusted they would rise to the challenge, and they did.

The level of trust was extraordinary, and a major factor in the facility’s rapid and significant improvement. The result: from always being ranked in the basement to number one, ahead of 25 other facilities, in only 14 months. Without that trust, it would have been impossible. Giving trust first paid huge dividends.

Read the short version of the Turnaround Story at diyleadingchange.com.

Quick Lesson Guide

Make it your own. The questions, words, and quotes here are examples that have worked for us. Use them, or change them to fit your style, your group, the circumstances, and your organization. Facilitate and lead.

  1. Start with what they’ve already learned. Ask, “What did we learn from Who Do You Trust?” Let them give it back to you. They’re recalling memories from the session and their own experience, not a fancy list of words.
  2. Open it up. “Let’s talk a little more about trust. Say you want someone who hardly knows you to trust you. Where would you start?” Let the group answer, and get the dialogue going. You’re building trust by letting them share and listen to each other. They’ll have their own ideas and examples. They probably won’t come up with “Give trust to get trust,” but if they do, even better.
  3. Name it and own it. Propose it out loud: “I’ve studied trust a lot, and I have a recommendation, one I didn’t think of on my own at first: You have to give trust to get trust.”
  4. Create a dialogue on what giving trust first means. Ask, “Why would anybody openly trust someone they don’t know? Do you keep your guard up? Do you question their motives? Have you been burned, and how did it happen?” Openly giving trust is a risk most people won’t take.
  5. Look at it from both sides. Openly giving trust is taking a risk. You’re the one seeking trust, not them, so what’s in it for them? Comment, “Surely we’ve all been burned at some point when we openly gave trust.” Then ask, “If someone takes the risk of trusting you to do the right thing, how does that affect you? They’re not asking you to return it.” Ask for examples as both the giver and the receiver, and what happened: “Has anyone given trust and been burned? Did you finally earn their trust? How?” Expand on it with the group, and lead them there: you take a risk, you go first, you start by trusting them.
  6. Expect to get burned. We’ve all been hung out to dry. It’s going to happen. They don’t know you yet, so they may not do the right thing, or may not tell you what you don’t know. When it happens, it’s okay to let them know, in the right way: “I trusted you, and you let me down.” No threats, no punishment. If it’s the right thing to do, saying it in front of others can add impact, but judge the circumstances.
  7. A first step to being trusted. What makes them want to trust you? The fact that you trust them. It’s only one step, maybe a very small one, but it’s noticed, it opens a door, and you have to start somewhere. In general, if you follow what you learned in Who Do You Trust?, people will notice you walking the walk. But when you purposely give trust to get trust, it’s a direct, big step with a person or group you want, or need, to trust you.
  8. Set the expectation. Wrap up the session as a tip for building trust, and remind the group: “This is how we get work done here. I’m going to trust you first because I want your trust in return.” If you’re the leader, make it a promise: “I’ll go first.”
  9. Close with the saying. “Give trust to get trust.”

For leaders

This is a leadership skill as much as a lesson. When you teach managers to be trusted more, tell them plainly: “You’re going to get burned. It’s okay. Don’t take a high risk, and don’t take it personally. It’s just the way it is. You earn trust. It doesn’t just show up.”

Start small. Give trust where the risk is low, and keep giving it. Every time you make the effort, it’s seen and felt, and others notice too. It’s okay to get burned a little as you earn trust.

Demonstrate it. The leader shows it every day. If you’re trustworthy, people will figure that out. If you’re not, they’ll see right through you.

In a stubborn case, ask the direct question. “What would it take for you to trust me?” It takes courage to ask, but it makes people think, and it shows you’re willing to take the extra step to earn their trust. You’re being open, honest, and upfront, which is what being trustworthy looks like.

What not trusting costs. In the Turnaround, my controller’s desk was buried in paper. Hourly employees wrote production numbers by hand on forms, and her accounting clerk spent the day keying them into the system. The controller herself spent a couple of hours a day on it, time she could have spent on much more important work for the facility.

Why? When I asked, she said she didn’t trust the people on the floor to enter the numbers themselves. It made no logical sense, and I told her so: “You trust them to write it down, but not to key it in?” I challenged her, “What’s the worst that can happen if they enter it themselves?” I asked her to think about it, and left it at that.

Without telling me, she reluctantly let go of a decades-old habit of not trusting the operators’ capabilities. All the double work disappeared overnight. Not a single complaint from the floor. Through normal attrition, the clerk’s position, and $50,000 a year in wages and benefits, went away. It was her first step in the Turnaround toward letting go and taking the risk to trust the workforce. She quickly grew into a major contributor to the facility’s success, driving many of the changes that provided the facility’s information processes and productivity measures. Because of our turnaround success, those were eventually recognized and shared across the entire company.

After the session

  • Use the saying. “Give trust to get trust.” You’ll know when it’s needed. It’s especially effective in the early stages of a change initiative, or when someone is new. For example, when your managers are learning to delegate tasks and decisions: “They’ll get it done. Give trust to get trust.”
  • Keep living it until you hear it or see it in action. When people start doing it or saying it to each other, they own it. Let them know you noticed, with a pat on the back or a “Good job.”
  • Facilitate it for everyone. Same lesson, same way, same name.

New to “Who Do You Trust?” Start there. Download the free guide (PDF), which includes the full, ready-to-run session.

Preston, DIY Leading Change


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *